Friday, June 03, 2005

So much to say, and such little time to say it.

I am having difficulty finding an intelligent, and example-supported argument for my issue of the day.

I was going to write about generosity, but after reading a few headlines, decided that it was more pertinent to write about desecration. I've been trying to ignore the Koran flushing stories that have been saturating the news over the last couple of weeks, but I've finally given in and read about it.
Personal Perspective:

I am as baffled in reading these accounts as I usually am when I read about it's obvious correlation, flag burning. Why do you care? If your devotion to an idea is so incredibly deep, it should not be shaken by another person's lack of devotion to that idea, or even their repugnance to it. Having devotion and belief do not result in shouting matches, anger, protests and violence. The result of a strong foundation is peace. You know that what you believe cannot be destroyed by the destruction of a mass produced symbol of that belief. Let it go.

But, we're all human, and when we disagree we tend to get a little pissy with each other. Especially when we're insecure about something. You're insecure about whether you've lived the life that will lead you to paradise, someone else is insecure about whether or not whether or not they are going to hell for buying too many ipods and cheating on their spouse. The end result of insecurity is violence, anger, shouting matches and protests I suppose.

From a political perspective:

I can understand why this is a fire that needs to be put out, but probably never will be. People are at war with thier idea of our idea of them. We are disrespectful, arrogant and corrupt. Our actions are in direct violation of their beliefs in many cases, and stories like this only go to prove the point of the so called "muslim extremists." This batch of stories has served to keep people angry at us for yet another insensitivity to their way of life, and in the long run we cannot afford to have a nearly worldwide anger at "our" behavior smouldering. Eventually Rome will be fighting a battle on too many fronts.

It is interesting to me that we are inherently a hipocritical nation. We have, in our own tumultuous way, embraced all different manner of beliefs. As a result of this there will always be a redneck willing to prove our ignorance and insensitivity to other cultures, a fat tourist who wants to eat McDonalds in the Forbidden City, a loud Skater Kid who plays with the remains in the Parisian catacombs, and millions of us to sit back and do nothing about it, because we are sure that we will never be heard in the din and apparent chaos of the melting pot furnaces.

Sorry, no links, you've read it, just plain old opinion.

3 Comments:

At 5:26 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

interesting. i think that the reason for people to get into shouting matches over personal devotions is from a much greater force then mear personal insecurities. i beleave that it dates back to when we as a species first looked at our own hands and continplated our past, present, future and fears. we have live by certian codes, honor if you will. primal instincts dictate that we defend what we feel belongs to us or that is our responsiblity. i think that ideas are just part of that. in my travels accross this country i have found that most people are far to concerned with their immediate gratification to see the "big picture". ignorance and mental laziness is not limited uneducated country folk. it permeates to all segments of humanity.

some people are lucky enough to be brought up in open families that tolerate others and welcomes difference to the table. some have to climb "the mountain" so to speak to learn inner peace and kindness to others while still being able to hold their own identities. and unfortinatly others fight for their entire excistance and all they have is their ideas and the hope that it will be better in another life.

i think the story represents this counrties own internal struggles rather than that of the blind allegiance of others. a magizine so wanted expose the infidelities of a cause that they find wrong and unjust, that they irrisponsibly printed an article that resulted in the death of others. even though the cause is worthy, the result must be called into question.

thank you for your time sorry for the poor grammer and spelling if there is any. math is more my thing.

 
At 8:56 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

hours after i typed the above comment i read an AP article that stated there had been what the pentigon called isolated incidents of the desicration of the Quran.
http://apnews.myway.com/article/20050605/D8AH5FT80.html

 
At 10:16 AM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Oddly enough, we are in disagreement on this one.

I have no idea why people get so wound up about their symbols and beliefs, I really don't understand it. So be it...

However, I think it is absolutely ridiculous that we 'have to put out this fire'. Have you noticed that the particular culture in question has no respect for the beliefs and symbols of others? Do I see any apologizing for the Taliban's destruction of the world's oldest representation fo the Buddha? For the bombing of synagouge and seder? The disrespect for our culture is rampant... But someone kicks a f'in book across the floor and the free world prostrates itself to apologize to a bunch of 3rd world ignoramuses. Scratch yourself in a mosque, and you'll cause an international incident... stone a women to death because her hair is uncovered and, well, you know, cultural relevancy. You have to respect their culture. They don't respect mine... fuck em. I want to start a Koran desecration website... I'll desecrate bibles and Torahs if it makes you feel like I'm being more 'fair'. You know I generally don't rant...but this one set me off. So sorry.

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home